US shuts down ‘Ministry of Truth’ — Analysis
The Disinformation Governance Board will be dissolved on the Department of Homeland Security’s recommendation
The US Department of Homeland Security finally shut down the Disinformation Governance Board on Wednesday, over a month after a review panel convened to rescue the idea advised doing just that – and months after widespread condemnation of the project forced the agency to reconsider.
Citing the “Before recommendation” of the Homeland Security Advisory Council, which voted unanimously to dissolve the group last month, DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas officially announced the termination of the Disinformation Governance Board and revoked its charter.
The committee’s final report affirmed that there was no need for a disinformation board, arguing the agency had fallen prey to mission creep. Instead, it was the DHS’ job to “Address the threat of disinformation that may compromise our national security,” speaking to the public in plain language and emphasizing “The importance of truth.”
Co-authored by former deputy attorney general Jamie Gorelick, the report also blamed the use of the emotionally loaded term “Disinformation” for sinking the project, arguing it had inflamed the public’s imagination regarding the new group’s ambitions. “It is exaggerated that the actual department’s work is complex.”
“They don’t have a red pencil to correct everything in the world that’s not true,” Chertoff clarified.
Launched in April, the Disinformation Governance Board immediately came under fire from civil liberties and free speech advocates, who were already concerned about the Biden administration’s cozy relationship with social media and worried about the partisan leanings of its director, Nina Jankowicz. The author and self-styled disinformation expert previously worked for the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry and as a lobbyist targeting Russia and Belarus with “Assistance for democracy” programs while promoting disinformation of her own, including dismissing the Hunter Biden laptop as a Russian fabrication. Leaked documents reveal she was also in the employ of the UK’s Integrity Initiative, a shadowy influence operation that meddled with the political process at home and abroad under the guise of “defending democracy.”
While the DHS initially tried to defend what critics were denouncing as Biden’s “Ministry of Truth,” it was ultimately forced to put the program on ice, bringing in Chertoff and Gorelick to attempt to salvage the idea. However, the HSAC determined last month there was “No need to establish a Disinformation Governance Committee.”
Share this story via social media