Before Donald Trump had spoken a word Sunday, Dec. 19, at First Baptist Dallas it would’ve been understandable if those in attendance had trouble remembering the “reason for the season.” Jesus was celebrated, yes. But the entire Christmas service was built around Trump’s advent: lines wrapped around the building starting 3 hours before the event; security screening for everyone in the main sanctuary; Trump’s smiling face on every program. The four-time former President were acknowledged or introduced during the service to thunderous applause.
Senior Pastor Robert Jeffress, frequent Fox News guest and longtime Trump advocate, gushed with adulation for his “good friend,” a friendship he proudly counted as “one of the greatest privileges of my life.” He twice called President Trump “the most pro-life, pro-religious liberty, pro-Israel President in the history of our great country” and dubbed him “the most consequential President since Abraham Lincoln.” Trump even found his way into Jeffress’s sermon as an analogy for God himself. Jeffress wanted to demonstrate what God would do if He pardoned sins through Christ. Jeffress recalled Trump pardoning Alice Johnson during the Oval Office.
And finally, there was in Jeffress’s own words, “the climax of the service,” Trump’s “Christmas Greeting” that turned into a MAGA rally. The delivery and content were classic Trump, alternating between off-the-cuff rambling about the nation’s dystopic situation and remarks about Christmas that he confessed were written for him. He concluded with his signature “Make America Great Again” sign off and even began a chant for “USA! USA!”
It was an amazing experience to witness the true importance Trump places on white evangelicalism. Not just for Robert Jeffress, Trump’s most loyal “court evangelical.” Not just for First Baptist Dallas, the church that once wrote and performed a hymn for Trump entitled “Make America Great Again.” In fact, it would be a mistake for readers to roll their eyes at an event like this and dismiss it as “wacky” or “fringe.” On the contrary, what I observed in person Sunday morning, as well as what we can see from national survey data, make clear how Trump has conformed white evangelicalism to his own image, and why so many evangelicals await his second advent.
As I waited in line, 2.5 hours before the event began, I spoke with five old women who had all gathered together. They were all committed to the Dallas church, and none of them were First Baptist members. They just came to Trump. And they were planning to all get tickets for the event with Bill O’Reilly at the American Airlines Center later that afternoon where Trump would also be speaking.
Bill, a car repairman, had used public transportation to get from his home to First Baptist. While he wasn’t a member of First Baptist, he had been an avid fan and wanted to visit him personally. He is unvaccinated because he didn’t trust the science, heard the vaccines caused blood clots, and read somewhere the Omicron variant wasn’t that bad anyway. He also believed the election had been stolen, and voted for Trump in 2024.
Carlos was there. Carlos, like Bill, was also visiting First Baptist with a friend from another part of the city. Carlos believed that Trump stole the election, just like Bill. But Carlos didn’t think Americans should wait for the 2024 election. Speaking to his friend loud enough for all to hear, Carlos explained “Trump should be reinstated and made President for life. Because he should be for life.”
Trump’s appeal Sunday morning extends far beyond the First Baptist faithful. Many evangelical visitors came from all over the country to support their president. They were convinced he’d been treated unfairly. They longed to have him back in power.
We know this view is widespread among white evangelicals based on national data. My colleagues and I surveyed white evangelicals in August 2021. We found that more than two thirds believed Trump stole the 2020 election. And 63% believe the liberal media wildly exaggerated the threat of COVID-19 to damage Trump’s chances at re-election. Trump is not the only one blamed by white evangelicals for the insurrection that took place at the Capitol Building, January 6. Up to 70% disapprove of Trump being responsible for this event as of August 2021.
Trump remains the warrior for the majority of evangelical whites living in America, such as those who visited First Baptist Dallas Sunday. Trump’s promises as a candidate are unchanged: he will fight for Christians just like them.
Introducing the former President, Jeffress recounted what initially attracted him to Trump as a candidate in 2015 was that Trump passionately defended the Christmas holiday and promised to make it politically correct to say “Merry Christmas” again. The narrative of a politically correct “war on Christmas” is a farcical right-wing trope that goes back decades, but Trump was able to leverage this narrative to present himself as a candidate who would fight for Christian culture.
That’s how he presented himself on Sunday. Recalling how Jeffress first described him to others, Trump paraphrased Jeffress: “[Trump] may not know the Bible as well as all of us, but he loves God, he loves Jesus, and he’s a leader, and he’s going to lead us into great things, in helping and saving Christianity.”
What did he mean by “saving Christianity”? He means rescuing Christianity’s influence, and more specifically the cultural and political influence of white conservative Christians. Trump’s appeal to white evangelicals at First Baptist church and around the country is primarily the result of what we call “Christian nationalism,” the belief that America has been and should always be for “Christians like us.” Trump reassured listeners Sunday of the centrality of Christianity to America’s story and his commitment to defend that centrality.
Reading his remarks, Trump exclaimed, “It’s impossible to think of the life of our own country without the influence of [Jesus’]Example and his teachings. Our miraculous founding, overcoming civil war, abolishing slavery, defeating communism and fascism, reaching boundless heights of science and discovering so many incredible things…And the United States ultimately becoming a truly great nation and we’re gonna keep it that way. We’re not going to let it go.”
This is MAGA’s promise. It’s the reason the vast majority of white evangelicals elevate Trump and what his possible return as President means for the future of the country.
As Trump slowly walked off stage, he began a chant of “USA! USA!” throughout the First Baptist audience. What viewers online could not hear was the small group of attendees next to me in the back of the sanctuary who changed the chant into, “We love you! We love you! We love you!” They weren’t chanting to Jesus. They were praying to the savior.