If Biden Removes China Tariffs, Would It Help Tame Inflation?
Consumers in merica are suffering from rising prices for everything, including gas and eggs. There are myriad reasons for the inflation—which hit a 40-year high in June—and President Joe Biden is reportedly considering lifting tariffs on some Chinese goods to rein it in.
Biden, who has called inflation “the bane of our existence,” said in May that his administration is evaluating how to best move forward on existing tariffs on China. Former President Donald Trump put on tariffs up to 25% against China in a trade war. They cover Chinese imports worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
Higher prices will be on the minds of American voters in midterm elections in November, and virtual talks between China’s Vice Premier Liu He and U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen on July 5 fueled speculation that tariffs could be lifted soon.
“With high inflation becoming a politically toxic issue, the Biden administration is clearly eager to take whatever policy actions are under its purview to corral rising prices,” says Eswar Prasad, a professor of economics and trade policy at Cornell University and the former head of the IMF’s China Division. “The imperative of doing whatever is possible to rein in inflation is probably overriding concerns about any political blowback from the perception of a softening of U.S. policies towards China,” he adds.
However, will Biden really lift tariffs and how would it benefit the American consumer? Here’s what to know.
Is Biden going to raise tariffs?
On Tuesday, the White House stated that it was still considering options and appears divided on this issue. Yellen said this month that some cuts might be warranted and that some of the tariffs “ended up being paid by Americans, not by the Chinese, hurt American consumers and businesses.”
Late June saw U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai tell a Senate Subcommittee it was crucial to safeguard U.S. commercial interests. “The China tariffs are…a significant piece of leverage, and a trade negotiator never walks away from leverage,” she said.
Learn More Surprise! This Surprising Fact Could Reduce Inflation
The U.S. Trade Representative’s office had received more than 400 requests to keep tariffs on Chinese goods in place, including from a committee of 24 labor unions, as of late Tuesday, according to Reuters.
“Strong pressure is coming from U.S. labor unions to continue the tariffs, fearing job losses due to increased outsourcing of manufacturing to China,” says Doug Barry, an official at the non-profit U.S.-China Business Council, which represents about 200 companies that trade and do business with China.
However, he says that evidence has shown that certain sectors have suffered job losses due to tariffs. “Weakened demand for China imports means less economic activity generated by those imports: fewer truck drivers, salespeople, accountants, and less tax revenue for local governments where the U.S. companies do business,” he says.
The government might not lift all tariffs.
Clete Willems, a former top White House trade negotiator told CNBC’s Squawk Box Asia on Wednesday that moves to lift some China tariffs would likely to be “modest”—perhaps $10 billion out of over $360 billion that are currently being imposed on China—in the short-term.
Many U.S. industries are against tariffs
David Dollar, senior fellow at Brookings Institution, said that removing all tariffs would only have a small effect on prices, which could lead to a reduction in many product prices. “Some of that would work via supply chains as U.S. firms import a lot of components from China and eliminating the tariffs would make the chains operate more smoothly.”
But any tariff reductions are likely to be focused on consumer goods such as electronics “where any price reductions might be most visible to consumers,” says Prasad, of Cornell. But, he says, “it is not obvious that the tariff reductions will pass through into lower prices at a time of strong consumer demand.”
According to a June Peterson Institute for International Economics report, broad trade liberalization would average save American households $797. But trade representative Tai criticized the study, calling it “something between fiction or an interesting academic exercise” and Yellen has warned that cuts would not be a “panacea” for easing high inflation.
A potential tariff cut might not provide the Biden administration with the political push it seeks.
There is a risk that “reductions in tariffs might at best have a limited and delayed impact on inflation, and would highlight the government’s impotence in managing inflation with the very limited policy tools at its disposal,” says Prasad. “Clearly, a tariff reduction would benefit both countries, but reducing tariffs without any concessions or commitments from China could result in unpalatably high political costs for the Biden administration relative to the economic benefits.”
Still, Barry says that members of the U.S.-China Business Council oppose the tariffs, “because they do more harm than good.” He says lifting tariffs would be meaningful for U.S. companies as some firms have “paid hundreds of millions of dollars in extra tariff fees to the U.S. Treasury.” He cites one of the last loudspeaker makers in the U.S., which complains that his products are no longer competitive because of the 25% tariffs on some components he imports from China.
Says Barry: “We want them all lifted, reciprocated by China, and negotiations restarted immediately on resolving the growing list of trade and other disagreements between the two largest economies in the world.”
Here are more must-read stories from TIME