s tensions between China and the U.S. have grown in recent months, I’ve been pondering the durability of the superpowers’ long-standing engagement on climate change. In an interview in April with John Kerry—a few weeks after Russia invaded Ukraine—I asked the United States’ top climate diplomat if Washington and Beijing could continue to work together on climate change if China supported the Kremlin’s war.
His answer didn’t provide a lot of reassurance. “We’ve had a couple of Zoom meetings and we’re really trying to find out just how connected the issues will be,” he said. On Aug. 5, that cooperation fell apart when Beijing announced it would suspend climate talks with the U.S. in response to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan—which China regards as a renegade province.
A lack of dialogue between the world’s two largest emitters is worrying, and the politicization of the climate agenda is a dangerous new road. A rift may make the U.S. clean energy transition more difficult, given its dependence on China’s technology exports; it may also hurt global efforts to stop climate change.
Learn More America’s Inflation Reduction Bill is about to jumpstart. Climate Policy and Change the World
The countries made significant progress together, including the securing of global cooperation to implement the 2015 Paris Agreement. The nations also announced last year at the COP26 summit their intention to work together in reducing methane emissions. In September 2021, Chinese President Xi Jinping said that the county will stop financing overseas coal projects, a pledge that some experts say wouldn’t have happened without international engagement. “I don’t necessarily think that this commitment would have been made by China voluntarily without any international engagement, including U.S. engagement,” says Li Shuo, of Greenpeace East Asia, in Beijing.
“When we talk about the U.S.-China climate engagement over the last decade it’s pretty much a single storyline of cooperation and engagement,” says Li. “If we’re going to introduce more confrontation, competition, or even just disengagement, I don’t think that’s conducive to moving the global climate agenda forward.”
This story was first published in the Climate is everything newsletter. Register here
That doesn’t mean either country will stop doing its domestic homework. China’s coal production hit record levels in 2021, but Beijing has pledged to peak its emissions before 2030 and to reach carbon neutrality by 2060. China is adding more renewable energy capacity than any other country, and it’s a leader in key green technologies such as electric vehicles and batteries. That’s unlikely to change as Beijing continues to strive for energy security and economic growth—and contends with a public that’s increasingly concerned with environmental issues. Qin Gang, China’s Ambassador to America, stated that on TwitterChina announced on August 9th that it will continue to adhere to its climate goals.
Inflation Reduction Act (USA) aims at boosting domestic manufacturing of renewable energy technology. But that won’t happen overnight. The U.S. is still dependent on China in order to obtain solar components. “China controls most of the world’s solar hardware capacity, the largest EV market, the bulk of the world’s battery production, most of its rare earths production, and some of the few wind turbine companies (onshore and offshore) making profits these days, it’s just hard to see how China cutting cooperation on climate change with the U.S. hurts China,” says Norman Waite, a Hong Kong-based energy finance analyst for the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
Learn More China and the United States need to put aside their rivalry and focus on one enemy: Climate Change
But now, more than ever, cooperation between nations matters, says Joanna Lewis, director of the Science, Technology and International Affairs program at Georgetown University: “While the U.S. and other countries have announced plans to scale up clean energy manufacturing, realistically this will take many years, and we are running out of time to decarbonize our energy sectors.”
The energy transition could be made more complicated if tensions keep rising. Even before Pelosi’s stopover in Taiwan, the U.S.’s increasingly tough stance on China has caused supply chain disruptions, and some in the industry have argued that tariffs hurt U.S. companies and consumers. In February, U.S. President Joe Biden extended Trump-era tariffs—aimed to help domestic manufacturers—on some Chinese solar products. And in recent weeks, some Chinese solar panel suppliers have had shipments to the U.S. detained or sent back by U.S. customs agents trying to enforce a law that blocks most imports from China’s Xinjiang region over concerns about forced labor, according to the Wall Street Journal.
Although human rights concerns should not be neglected, U.S.-China cooperation on climate change will be essential if we want the world to continue living. As Michael Davidson, an assistant professor of engineering and policy at the University of California San Diego, says: “U.S.-China engagement on climate is sorely needed in areas of trade, supply chains, and technology, to ensure that bilateral tensions do not irreparably harm the ability to reduce emissions in either country and the world.”
Here are more must-read stories from TIME
