Letters
Subject:
Freedom Will Conquer...
I would like to start by addressing this
email directly to Mr. Pawlick. I just came across your book while cataloging
the library books at an elementary school in Boston. To be completely
fair, I did not read through the whole book, so I am not passing judgment
on the contents of the book.
I do want you to know that as a teacher/woman
of color..."Black" as you so ignorantly say in the beginning of your
book, I am completely offended by what you call a dedication to your
grandchildren.
I suppose that you think that you should
be applauded for not being concerned about your daughter and her "black"
husband. And as for your concern for your grandchildren, I am surely
as concerned as you.
When you talk about them not being welcomed
by the "haters" among "the blacks".....I am very offended. I come from
a family of people who are all shades of brown and we sure don't call
each other "the blacks"... And although there may be certain people
in your grandkids lives that may treat them differently or unfairly,
It is more likely that it isn't about the shade of "black" that they
are, but more about them being "black" at all which doesn't stem from
people of color for the most part.
When you talk about the blood under their
skin being Italian (white, right?) Jewish (white,right?) German, Irish
and Belgian (all white, right?) Why do you choose not to say just white?
You instead describe them as Ethnic characteristics....."BLACK"
is NOT an Ethnic characteristic. Being "black" is NOT a cultural characteristic.....And,
what in God's name makes you think that "BLACK" is one dimensional.
My brothers and sisters are ALL shades of dark brown to "white."
As a "BLACK" woman, the blood that runs
through my veins is Jamaican, Cuban, Native American, Jewish, African
American, and Eastern Indian.
THE FACT THAT YOU COULDN'T DESCRIBE ANYTHING ELSE OTHER THAN "BLACK"
IS APPAULING TO ME!!!!!
I can't believe that after 7 years of
teaching, I haven't come across your book before. But I am glad that
I have so I can make sure it doesn't stay in our library.
I will continue to read your book against
my better judgment and I am sure that you will hear back from me again
soon.
Thank you for your time.
Jennipher Burgess
Atty.
Pawlick's Response
Dear Ms. Burgess,
Thank you for taking the time to write
me about "Freedom." I always enjoy hearing from readers,
no matter what they say and no matter how busy I am. I hope
you find the time to "read through the whole book." I will
be happy to send you a free copy if you will tell us where to send it.
I was writing in "Freedom" about people
in the United States whose ancestors used to be slaves and have been
called 1) negroes, 2) blacks and 3) African Americans. I
know of no other name.
If you believe I should have said "people
of color" that is fine with me.
I look forward to hearing back from you
and I hope it is soon.
Thanks for writing.
Attorney J. Edward Pawlick