TABLE OF CONTENTS

Transcript of Oral Argument before Single Justice Greaney on February 5, 2003
Granting Relief in Marriage Scandal Would Create More Trust in Courts, SJC Is Advised
Sidebar: Three Minute Summary
Sidebar: Full Text of Brief

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ii

QUESTIONS PRESENTED 1

STATEMENT OF THE CASE 1

 

Prior Proceedings

Statement of Facts

ARGUMENT 5

 

I. FACTUAL AND LEGAL BACKGROUND 5

II. IS THERE ANYONE WITH A RIGHT TO BE HEARD? 8

III. WHAT REMEDY IS AVAILABLE WHEN CITIZENS HAVE
SPENT OVER $1.7 MILLION ON AN ART. 48 INITIATIVE AND HAVE SCRUPULOUSLY DOTTED EVERY "I" AND CROSSED EVERY "T"
AND YET THE LEGISLATURE AND GOVERNOR REFUSE TO OBEY
THE CONSTITUTIONAL REQUIREMENT THAT THE LEGISLATURE
VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT? 13

IV. IS IT AN UNUSUAL REMEDY THAT THE PLAINTIFFS
SUGGEST? 16

V. DEFENDANT'S ARGUMENTS ANSWERED SERIATIM 17

VI. IS IT TOO MUCH TO EXPECT A FAIR VOTE IN
MASSACHUSETTS IN 2003? 28

VII. CONCLUSION 36



 




Copyright 2008 ©All Rights Reserved
MassNews.com®
508-410-2087